What is tactile defensiveness?
Tactile defensiveness is a term used to describe the reaction that occurs when someone is very sensitive to touch. Someone who experiences tactile defensiveness will be more sensitive to touch compared to others. Often their skin is more sensitive to every day things like clothes and hair brushing. They may report that certain touch is painful. Children and adults with autism frequently report tactile defensiveness. Children and adults with touch sensitivity may display the following sensory processing symptoms:
Dislikes feeling of certain fabrics
Dislikes socks, especially the seams and has a preference for the position of sock seams
Difficulty with wearing shoes
Avoidance of messy textures such as finger paint, glue and playdough; and sometimes dry textures like sand
Fussiness with food textures, including avoidance of mixed textures (e.g. lasagne) or foods with some lumps (e.g. yoghurt with fruit pieces)
Dislikes hugs and/or kisses, might rub away kisses
Difficulty with teeth brushing
Challenges with haircuts and hair brushing
Difficulty when cutting finger or toe nails
Dislikes the feeling of clothing tags
Kim gives a brief description of tactile defensiveness
What causes tactile defensiveness?
As we discussed in our article on the touch system, there are three types of touch sensory inputs. These are light touch, discriminative touch and touch pressure. If you haven’t read this post, we recommend you read if first before reading any further. It will help with your understanding of tactile sensitivity.
You can also learn more about the touch system in our free course ‘Introduction to Sensory Processing.’
Types of touch
In addition to light touch, discriminative touch and touch pressure, the skin also receives information about pain, temperature and vibration. Light touch and pain typically warn the body about potential threats, so are often called ‘protective sensations’. They send sensory information through a different nerve pathway to the discriminative touch sensations. A nerve pathway is like a road that the sensory signals travel along to the brain. Usually, once these protective sensations warn the brain that something has touched the skin, the brain then receives extra information from the discriminative touch pathway to let it know what that something was.
For example, if you touch something hot, the brain will immediately acknowledge the feeling of pain. As a result, the brain will make the body move your hand away. Next, you will receive extra sensory information from the discriminatory touch pathway. This lets you know more about where the pain is and also that it feels like a burn. The brain receives different sensory information from each pathway.
As another example, if your hair is dangling in your face, the first time it touches your face you might get a surprise. You may not know exactly what the light touch sensation on your face was. However, extra information about that piece of hair will then go through the discriminatory touch pathway or you might brush your hand on your face and this will let the brain know it’s just a piece of hair. It is nothing to worry about and your brain will ignore it.
Sensory Integration – a theory behind tactile defensiveness
Jean Ayres thought tactile hypersensitivity occurs because the brain pays too much attention to light touch and protective sensations from the skin. Instead of listening to the extra information available from the discriminative pathway, the brain keeps paying attention to the light touch and protective sensations. These sensations are designed to alert the body to a problem or threat. They are designed to keep the body safe. So, each time the brain receives a message from these pathways it initially thinks that something might be wrong. It gets ready to protect the body. This is called a fight, flight or freeze response. Jean Ayres thought that the brains of children and adults with tactile defensiveness interpret ordinary touch sensations, such as clothing or a hug, as a threat. Their brains pay more attention to light touch sensations than the brains of children without touch sensitivity.
This helps to explain the behaviours that are seen in children or adults with tactile defensiveness. Their responses to everyday touch can often result in meltdowns, arguments and avoidance. This is because their brains are feeling that touch in the same way you might if you touched something hot or ran into a spider web. The everyday touch activates their brain’s protective system and triggers a fight, flight or freeze response. Some adults with touch sensitivity have also reported that certain everyday touch sensations feel painful.
Difficulty ignoring touch sensations
Children and adults who experience tactile sensitivity may also find it more difficult to ignore touch sensations. A comparison would be the feeling of having a stone in your shoe, a stone that is very annoying and constantly drawing your attention until you take off your shoe and remove it. For children or adults with tactile hypersensitivity, sometimes it is everyday touch that feels like the stone. This could be something like the tag on the back of their t-shirt, or the feel of a certain fabric. Their brains cannot ignore the feeling and they just need to get away from it, in the same way you want to remove the stone.
How can I find out if I am, or my child is, tactile defensive?
There is currently no formal test like a blood test or an x-ray to find out if someone is sensitive to touch. Tactile defensiveness is also not a formal diagnosis which your doctor could diagnose you with. It can occur with other conditions such as autism or Asperger’s. It can also occur alongside other sensory processing issues. An occupational therapist is the best professional to seek advice from. They will use questionnaires and observations to determine if it is likely a child or adult has tactile defensiveness. A questionnaire, such as the Sensory Profile, will give a score for how the child or adult responds to touch. The therapist will also look at the individual questions to consider if these relate to touch sensitivity.
What can I do to help a child or adult with tactile defensiveness?
Warn the child prior to touching them – e.g. ‘Suzie I am just going to brush an eyelash off your face.’ / ‘John I am just going to fix your collar’
Use a firmer pressure when touching the child – don’t squeeze or hurt them but avoid being very light with your touch
Avoid tickling the child or adult. Sometimes children with touch sensitivity will laugh when tickled, but watch that this isn’t a nervous laugh indicating they are uncomfortable
Heavy work can be a helpful strategy to help to support children with tactile sensitivity. It is thought that the sensory inputs a child, or adult, receives from heavy tasks helps to regulate their touch sense. If you’re not familiar with heavy work, or need some ideas we discuss it further in our article – The Mystery of Heavy Work
Weighted products can be useful to help children to regulate
For some children, the Willbarger brushing protocol does make a difference. This protocol uses brushes with stiff bristles to help decrease touch sensitivity. It must be led by a trained occupational therapist and it is not the right solution for every child. It is recommended that you discuss the most appropriate option for your child with their occupational therapist
What else should I consider alongside touch sensitivity?
Relevant GriffinOT Resources to support touch sensitivity
If you are working with younger children or children with a cognitive age between 3-5, you may also find our book Sensory Group‘ helpful. Sensory Group is a step by step weekly programme that targets tactile sensitivity, joint attention and turn taking. It is a perfect resource for teachers working with children with autism or developmental delays who avoid messy play and show signs of tactile sensitivity.
Where to Next?
If you want to really understand the two touch pathways we recommend our free introduction to sensory processing. This one hour online course explores all senses including touch in further depth.
To learn more about weighted products we suggest article Weighted blankets, benefits, precautions plus when and why to use them.
We also explore additional ideas for self regulation here Sensory regulation strategies – what are they and how can they help your child?
To learn more about sound sensitivity we would recommend this article Auditory Sensitivity: 3 Things You Should Know.
You may also want to read more about sensory processing and autism we explore this topic here ASD and Sensory Processing Disorder.